Rating the Anime of Fall 2015

I’m a little late to the party, aren’t I?  To tell you the truth, my dear readers, I have not even settled on the shows I’m going to watch this season with the sole exception of Ojisan to Marshmallow, which is a very amusing short.  Feel free to give me your three favorite shows so far in the comments section below, and I promise to take a look at them.

fuyu no toki ni

Looking back at the anime of Fall 2016, the high scores I awarded to the shows struck me.  Have I become even less critical than normal?  Then, your humble blogger realized that last season’s worst shows haven’t ended, and I decline to rate shows until I see the ending–unless Beneath the Tangles requires one of me.  So, let me talk about the worst shows of the past season before I get to the good stuff.

Worst wine pour in anime ever.

Worst wine pour in anime ever.  Is that ketchup?

8)  The Perfect Insider (aka Subete ga F ni Naru)

The fact that such a well constructed show finds itself at the bottom speaks volumes to how good the Fall 2015 was.  The Perfect Insider‘s problem was that it strove to appear erudition and merely became abstruse.  The philosophical queries at the show’s beginning drew me in, but the show became less about metaphysics and human nature and more about trying to learn the psychology of the killer, Dr. Shiki Magata.  One might claim that learning Dr. Magata’s psychology helps us understand philosophical ideas and human nature.  But, the usefulness of any philosophy we derive from a person’s psyche depends greatly on their sanity.  Dr. Magata has a few cards short of a full deck, is five cans short of a six pack, four quarters short of a dollar, and, in brief, is mad as a hatter.  Since insanity is based in pride and not in reality, one learns very little philosophy indeed.

Differing morals


Saikawa’s moral education leaves much to be desired.

Nishinosono and Saikawa made for interesting protagonists.  I could not but favor the former, since all the interest in Dr. Magata flabbergasted me also.  There was some great voice acting and animation, but the next half needs to go a long way to offset this poor beginning.

Kou Omou


7) Utawarerumono: Itsuwari no Ken

I cringed when a commentator in a Beneath the Tangles podcast dismissed the original Utawarerumono as an anime merely for those with a predilection for furries.  (My high estimation of the show can be seen by its placement among my top 50 anime.)  However, that description applies to the sequel with unfortunate accuracy.  The first four episodes feature danger and intrigue, but are followed by some bland slice-of-life harem antics.  The characters were cute, several were hilarious, but the anime is not worth your time unless you love the franchise or furries.  As one of the former, I shall inflict another season on myself.

Can the harem grow anymore than it has?

Can the harem grow anymore than it has?

New Karula and New Touka

It was good to see Kagura and Touka again…even if Touka’s character was not what I remembered.


N.B. Angryjellyfish tells me that the second season is jarringly violent compared to the first.  That gives me some hope of the sequel not being a complete waste.


vlcsnap-2015-11-03-12h27m14s186 vlcsnap-2015-11-03-12h28m11s160

6) Heavy Object

If memory serves me right, iblessall had a terrific time lampooning this show on Twitter but could take no more than five episodes.  I perfectly understand why: the first five episodes were pretty stupid.  It’s as if someone threw in the heroes of 50/50, skimmed von Clausewitz on Brainy Quotes, and tossed in the the mentality of Tengen Toppa Guren Lagaan while still attempting some realism.  The commentary on the brutality of war against this background–especially with the excessive fanservice and S&M gags involving Captain Frolaytia–strike one as pure ridiculousness.


However, the anime somehow hits its stride after episode five, and I found the following episodes surprisingly enjoyable despite the ever-present goofiness.  As the action and plots become somewhat more reasonable, their commentary on warfare also does.  The backstory of Frolaytia vexed me by being its perfect absurdity; but I enjoyed about everything else about the second half, and I look forward to more.

vlcsnap-2015-11-03-12h24m39s638 vlcsnap-2015-11-03-12h24m52s416

Futari Kyoudai

5) The Anti-Magic Academy: 35th Test Platoon – ★★★ 1/2

I was happy when I convinced Jusuchin of A Journey through Life to watch and blog about this show.  The characters were all quite likeable, and I agree with Kaze’s assessment that the show gave constant entertainment throughout–even if I give it a full star higher.  It never became terribly profound, but the show made me deeply invested in the characters and their fates.  (If a story can do that, it’s a winner in my book.)  This show’s style reminded me much about Black Bullet and was about as fun for a harem fantasy.  The 35th Test Platoon had good animation, likable characters, great fights, and some gut-wrenching situations–everything I want in an anime.

Pass the Ammunition San-nin bikkuri

Shock and Awe

4) Ushio to Tora – ★★★

I believe that it was Genki Jason who referred to this show as “shonen done right,” which pithily explains the greatness of the show.  Shonen often gets looked down on for its hackneyed tropes, but Ushio to Tora never gave me the sense that I watched something derivative.  It had a resemblance to Inuyasha, but the manga was published prior to Inuyasha.  So, I cannot accuse Ushio to Tora of stealing from that splendid show.  (And if Rumiko Takahashi stole/borrowed some ideas from Ushio to Tora…well, it’s better than a world without Inuyasha.)  The way this show never gives Ushio an easy fight, creates an amusing anti-hero in Tora, and delves into the themes of loyalty, love, and self-sacrifice made for a very refreshing shonen.

End of Ushio to Tora

Sakurako-san hikari de

3) Beautiful Bones – Sakurako’s Investigation (aka Sakurako-san no Ashimoto ni wa Shitai ga Umatteiru) – ★★★

At one point, this show was my favorite of the season.  (I had placed the next two on the back burner.)  With beautiful animation, intriguing Holmesian mysteries, a great dynamic between the characters, and a heroine who reminds me much of Holo, this show had a ton to offer.  Like all Japanese mysteries, the main goal of unlocking the mystery was to understand the psychology of the actors.  Still, the mysteries presented some difficulty in solving, which is rare among anime outside of Case Closed.  Through various literary allusions, one could tell this show’s creator was a lover of literature, especially the works of Doyle’s famous sleuth, and that added a whole other level of enjoyment for me.



2) Seraph of the End: Battle in Nagoya – ★★★

Readers of this blog know how fond I was of the first season.  In artwork, the second season outdoes itself, striking me as a “wallpaper anime,” i.e. one with plenty of striking scenes worthy of gracing my computer screen.  Here’s a few examples:

vlcsnap-2015-10-29-11h59m36s656 vlcsnap-2015-10-29-12h00m19s818 vlcsnap-2015-10-29-12h08m15s605 vlcsnap-2015-10-29-15h29m39s409 vlcsnap-2016-01-13-10h28m15s395 vlcsnap-2016-01-13-10h30m09s988 vlcsnap-2016-01-13-16h54m49s059 vlcsnap-2016-01-13-17h01m25s808 vlcsnap-2016-01-13-17h03m36s763 vlcsnap-2016-01-14-12h27m45s842 vlcsnap-2016-01-14-12h29m28s094

(Okay, that was more than a few, but I really loved the artistry of this show!)  Also, the fights in this season became more intense and realistic in some respects.  (Who can forget Mikaela’s rash charge to kidnap Yuuichirou?)  The only thing that prevents me from giving the show more than four stars is its slow start, and the silliness of certain scenes.  Bring on another season!



1) Noragami Aragoto – ★★★★ 1/2

Remember how I said that I had only given the above rating to Arslan Senki and Eden of Grisaia?  I had not yet seen the second half of Noragami Aragoto.  This show had one of the slowest starts of this season, which caused me to place it on the backburner, but the latter half more than made up for that slow start.  Some of the fights and animation were spectacular, and the characters were very likable as always.


It feels odd that I can write so little about my favorite show of last season, yet write so much more about the shows I loved less.  But, this article has gone on quite long, and I thank my dear readers who have made it to the end!  Now to finally turn my attention to the new season and a review of The Wind Rises, which I finally got around to.

vlcsnap-2015-11-13-16h29m02s315 vlcsnap-2015-11-13-17h02m34s043 vlcsnap-2015-11-13-17h11m16s900 vlcsnap-2016-01-12-13h34m56s721

6 comments on “Rating the Anime of Fall 2015

  1. Japesland says:

    (Commenting on Utawarerumono):
    Since that podcast episode has gone up, I’ve played the original Utawarerumono game and rewatched the anime, and have come to some new conclusions.

    1) The original game is simply stunning. It hits the story and emotional cues at just the right time and with incredible force.

    2) The anime panders much less than the sequel, but is absolutely abysmally bad compared to the game. The CG and hand-drawn animation are horrendous, and the pacing is just the pits. Were it not for the ending’s twist and my general interest in Japanese history (since Utawarerumono parallels it), I would not give it any credit.

    That said, the game is among my top 10 favorite games and the anime in the bottom 25% of my anime list. But I have to give it credit for introducing me to the series. I loved the game so much I rewatched it despite hating it most of the time and I actually put down the cash for the video game sequel (which I am now playing) and am eagerly awaiting the next entry this year.

    As far as the current season, it definitely is more accurately described by what I said in the podcast. But knowing that the story of the original series didn’t really get amazing until the end is keeping me interested. Of course, I dropped the series a few episodes into cour 2 so I could get the optimal experience of the game, after which I will finish the anime 😛


    • That reminds me of how people talk about Lunar Legend Tsukihime: that the game is so much better than the anime–so much so that they say the anime does not exist. But, I have fond memories of the Utawarerumono anime, which kept me interested with the constant battles and turmoil Hakuoro faced in forging a nation. It also constantly surprised me with how many genres it managed to include in one show.

      Hope you enjoy the second Utawarerumono game.


  2. Cheers for the mention! 😀 Utawarerumono does seem to be going somewhere, but the pacing is ridiculous. Likely pandering over plot, as you say. It’ll have to get a move on if it wants to develop a decent story in the time remaining, unless they’re planning on more beyond this current series.

    Noragami Aragoto surprised me too, starting in my bottom 5 for the season due to its slow first episodes, but it soon shot up and made my top anime of 2015 list!

    Owari no Seraph’s second part was more enjoyable on the whole for me than the first series – all the battles happened on screen, at least! That ‘ending’ was a bit of a rushed mess though.

    My favourite three for the Winter season (excluding sequels): Boku dake ga Inai Machi, Shouwa Genroku Rakugo Shinjuu and Dimension W. 🙂


    • You’re welcome! I’ll be sure to check out your choices from the new season. I was especially surprised by how much production value Shouwa Genroku Rakugo Shinjuu got. The show ought to be awesome.


  3. MIB says:

    Interesting how different our tastes our yet so similar! “Noragami” and “Seraph Of the End” made it into my top 10 of 2015, while “Sakurako” I thought was okay, even if it kept switching from murder mystery to typical frippery.

    I must confess I dropped “Heavy object” after the first or second episode due to how the female lead was treated, while I ended up dropping “Perfect Insider”, as I fell behind and when I tried to pick it up again I had no clue what was going on – in fact I had no clue before that! :/


    • Yeah, Sakurako’s plot had it’s problems, and people say the presentation of the mysteries were flawed. These problems did not bother me as much because of how likable I found the characters.

      You have no idea how close I came to dropping Heavy Object and Perfect Insider! I likely kept watching them because of how bad they were. One needs to watch a few shows like that, right? Though, I was happy the action in Heavy Object got better after episode five, even if the uncomfortable fanservice did not. Perfect Insider was too talky and esoteric: they tried to pull off a Monogatari, but failed–even worse than Monogatari often fails at the same thing. 🙂


Legens, scribe sententias tuas.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s