Mirai Nikki: The Heretic Successor of Elfen Lied

Well, dear readers, I finally broke down and decided to watch Mirai Nikki due to my sister’s insistence.  I have seen about thirteen episodes of this well known series thus far, and find it rather enjoyable.  The first thing to strike me was how similar it seemed to Elfen Lied: the insane, pink-haired, crazed killer, many violent, bloody deaths, and the abnormal fighting abilities of the contestants.  Despite these similarities, there is a difference in mood between the two shows, which boils down to the variance with which they treat the concept of evil.  (I can see it all now: people who consider Elfen Lied a vacuous show are going to hate this article.)

elfen-lied-wallpaper-elfen-lied-2655661-1024-768 368579-futurediary1_super

Haven’t you noticed this yourselves?  The plot of Mirai Nikki is centered around a game prepared by “the god of time and space” in which the contestants annihilate each other in order to gain the god’s title.  Creating the setting of a game does much to minimize the effect of the atrocious crimes committed therein.  All the casualties become pawns in a chess game.  This takes away from the impact of say killing scores of school children, taking invalids hostage, wretchedly treating prisoners, and even creating a twisted young child to be killed for the purposes of the game–I’m referring to a diary holder.

future-diary-ep-2

Conversely, Elfen Lied causes us to feel sorrow whenever someone is slain or even when they are merely struck.  The sinfulness of the action strikes us.  I believe this involves the fact that Lynn Okamoto was probably influenced by the religion of the Lutheran minister who wrote the eponymous poem.  So, we are struck by a sense of sin pervading the show.  Lives are lost; but, the wickedness of these acts are not lost on us, as they tend to be in Mirai Nikki.  So, the main divergence between the two shows appears to be religious: the Christian God in Elfen Lied–albeit, with the Lutheran conception of the depravity of man tainting the world–vs. the rather Assyrian god of Mirai Nikki, who enjoys playing with other people’s lives.

nana-c003

The curious case of #9, Uryuu Minene, offers the most striking example of how Mirai Nikki‘s world misunderstands the problem of evil.  We are introduced to this character as a monster who’s willing to sacrifice school children in order to achieve her goals.  To speak plainly, she’s rather loathesome, right?  Then, she fails in her object due to Yukiteru taking out her eye, she suffers greatly in making her escape from the police, and endures humiliation, pain, and betrayal from the “justice” besotted contestant (the conception of justice held by this character makes one fear for how the manga-ka views justice himself), and goes on to become perhaps the most likeable character in the show–at least, in my case.  (Could it be a perceived resemblance to Revy of Black Lagoon?)

Then again, I might be reaching too hard or nostalgic for an old favorite.

Then again, I might be reaching too hard or nostalgic for an old favorite.

Revy.full.1318960

How is it that we can so easily warm up to a character who’s first shown us committing heinous crimes?  The suffering which followed her debut might be said to partially atone for her wrongs, but can they really be enough?  Her character even undergoes a change as she becomes level-headed, and we only rarely glimpse her maniacal smile.  And so, evil seems to result from insanity rather than malice.  We cannot really hold an insane person guilty, therefore no need for atonement.

future_diary-20-minene-nishijima-romance-love-kiss-blush

By the deep seated guilt of many of the characters, Elfen Lied acknowledges that, no matter what evil influences have twisted a person’s personality, they still sin by their own free choice.  This visibly taints their souls and places a burden of judgment upon them.  We, the viewers, sense this and develop true antipathy toward certain characters.

elfen_lied_lucy_1440x900_wallpaper_High

An exception to this rule in Elfen Lied is Lucy herself.  Her very guilt makes her sympathetic.  She would like to obtain forgiveness, and Kohta tries to give it to her.  However, Lucy knows in her heart of hearts that murder cannot be taken back, that the blood tainting her soul can’t be brushed aside or blamed on anyone else.  The only person who can erase such a thing is found in the lyrics of the opening song to that show: “O Lord, O Sacred Fire, have mercy!”  For God alone can forgive sins.  Excuses based on one’s mental state or tragic background don’t cut it.

elfen-lied1

Ultimately, Elfen Lied‘s biggest failure in understanding human nature is the doctrine of total depravity which runs through the show.  But, it still knows human nature better than Mirai Nikki.  This makes it the better show of these rather similar works.  So, what do you think, my dear readers?  Which show really has a better perception of human nature and the mystery of evil?

Advertisements

21 comments on “Mirai Nikki: The Heretic Successor of Elfen Lied

  1. circlecitadel says:

    I agree, There were many self-justifications through the series of Mirai Nikki that seemingly absolved them of any blame. For example the whole notion of the game is necessary, otherwise reality falls apart unless there is an heir to Deus; but, likewise, any actions of the diary holders are necessary, for this is how the game is decided. In a short phrase, the sacrifice of a few for the good of the many.

    On an other anime, have you been watching Psycho-Pass? Strong loss of the understanding of sin via psychology in this one (I mean, I imagine that was the author’s intent, the whole show being a dystopian genre). I’ve been thinking about writing on that soon.

    • I haven’t seen Psycho-Pass yet, but I ought to soon. The plot sounded very intriguing–even if they stole the main idea from Minority Report.

      I’ll be looking forward to your article!

  2. TWWK says:

    I find Elfen Lied to be vacuous, but I still enjoyed your article. 🙂

  3. […] Medieval Otaku compares how Mirai Nikki and Elfen Lied each demonstrate the nature of human sinfulness. [Medieval Otaku] […]

  4. […] UPDATE: Here’s a link to a defender of Elfen Lied, with an article on the newer series Mirai Nikki&#82…. […]

  5. […] response that didn’t make it in (though thankfully, someone else mentioned that irredeemable [or is it?] […]

  6. PoisonedTea says:

    You understanding of these anime’s are good

    I think you had missed something about Lucy. She has split personalty’s this is clear. At some point in Lucy’s life she decided(or almost decided) that all humans are not people. It is never said that could be the reason why others feel that way too.
    It most clear when Lucy says “I have never killed a person”.

    This does go both ways.
    The humans tend to feel the same about Lucy and other of her race too.(The few that know about them.)

    • That’s true: Lucy says she doesn’t think of human beings as people. But, I think that this involves lying to herself in some way. In the same way, an American during the Indian Wars might claim that American Indians are savages or subhuman, but you can see the effect on such people’s psyches of treating the Indians as if they were not people. Such people tended to become merciless and hate-filled, which is what we see in Lucy. Now, we see hunters killing deer or whatever animal they like, but their psyches do not undergo the same change. So, I think that perhaps Lucy’s guilt is even compounded by they fact that she tries to imagine human beings as nonpersons. And, especially by the end of the show, she cannot deny that she’s a murderer, which seems to be the ultimate obstacle in her having a complete reconciliation with Kouta.

      But, that’s my understanding of it. Thanks for your compliments!

  7. […] any rate, Girls und Panzer and Future Diary provided excellent entertainment with the later raising some interesting moral questions.  I rather enjoyed both, though I admit to Future Diary being somewhat of an acquired taste.  At […]

  8. Vincent says:

    I like elfen lied one of my favorite anime’s and this article is good but I will agree with you side of you opinion

    • Thanks! I’m glad that you liked the articles. It’s one of my great joys to draw connections between anime, and the similarity between Mirai Nikki and Elfen Lied really stood out.

  9. Bakers says:

    While I agree that Elfen Lied does portray human nature better, I still found Mirai Nikki the more enjoyable of the two.

    • Ha! Well, I enjoyed Elfen Lied more for all its darkness. The fact that the characters of Mirai Nikki tended to be devoid of conscience–as the indeed the entire world tended to be–made them feel less like real people. I could identify more with the characters of Elfen Lied who were afflicted with guilt, maybe because I’m Catholic. 🙂

      Anyway, they are both worthwhile shows. And, you know what they say: de gustibus non est disputandum.

  10. Leo Blaze says:

    I think both Elfen Lied and Mirai Nikki were good. And endings of both kept me hanging.

    • I agree. The manga of Elfen Lied gives a much more complete story. You might try that. Also, the mangaka’s Gokukoku no Brynhildr uses a similar plot to Elfen Lied, and is quite good up until the end of the Valkyria Arc. Afterwards, he does not know what to do with the story. He sadly seems to only be able to write one kind of tale.

  11. […] Medieval Otaku compares how Mirai Nikki and Elfen Lied each demonstrate the nature of human sinfulness. [Medieval Otaku] […]

  12. Luminas says:

    I think the whole basic problem when people write evil and write a tragic backstory in and it seems to make the character “gooder” IS a misunderstanding of sin….a deliberate one, perhaps. In a weird sense, I think we ourselves often fall towards the mistake of believing that the fact that we went through pain absolves of our sins. But pain doesn’t make you less guilty. It just makes you more likely to BE guilty of something. I’m not sure I exactly agree with the fact that a little rich girl who has never felt hunger and cold and abuse is on the same starting footing as a person who grew up in poverty in an abusive household……But I think that God knows that. And He is the ultimate judge.

    • That is very true. One can’t say that a thief is not guilty because he grew up without a father, surrounded by vicious people, and without a moral education. The most one can say is that he is less guilty because of his ignorance, lack of good examples, and, perhaps, want. For those reasons, he might deserve leniency–less time in jail or perhaps the choice of joining the Marines instead of jail time. (I’m not sure if the latter is still done.) Someone who’s suffered less and received a fine moral education seems to deserve less pity in our eyes. After all, he goes against his training, while the other imitates those around him and has less understanding of justice and goodness.

      The case of Lucy is a bit more complicated, because everyone knows in their heart of hearts that murder is wrong. Nevertheless, she seems not to have had parents and undergone atrociously bad experiences which warped her into, essentially, Satan’s tool for murder. (The spiritual battle between good and evil is much more apparent in the Elfen Lied manga.) Lucy forms the conception that she is not human and at war with humanity with each man, woman, and child being a combatant. I think that she knows what she is doing is wrong (the reason for her Lucy/Nyu schizophrenia), but allows the evil treatment she received at the hands of other people to continue to drive her. Nevertheless, the evil treatment she received makes us pity her and hope that she overcomes her drive for vengeance (or malice against the human race) and defeats the devil.

      Have you read the Elfen Lied manga? It’s grisly and explicit, but I thought the themes of it were pretty deep.

  13. […] response that didn’t make it in (though thankfully, someone else mentioned that irredeemable [or is it?] […]

Legens, scribe sententias tuas.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s